The Shore Grill & Fish House, North Queensferry, restaurant review

The Shore Grill & Fish House needs to navigate some troubled waters, says Gaby Soutar

Thereโ€™s a new bridge across the Firth of Forth.

If you live in Scotland, you will know this, unless you have been living in a cave.

Or you are my sister, who drove across the six-week-old Queensferry Crossing, with its white suspenders like the lines on a maths protractor, and didnโ€™t even notice.

She couldโ€™ve been doing a Herbie the Love Bug, or motoring across turtlesโ€™ shells, as long as it got her from a to b.

It took us a while to get a booking at this new restaurant, which, thanks to its location and view, has been rather busy with bridge botherers.

Itโ€™s part of a refurbished hotel, which looks as if itโ€™s been built from brown Lego bricks, and you arrive at the front door by looping around and under the end of the bridge, sort of like the beginnings of tying a tie.

Inside, and the plush design includes organic-looking wooden details on the ceiling, like the skeleton of a boat or a whaleโ€™s baleen.

The menu is well designed, from the team behind Edinburghโ€™s fancy Twenty Princes Street and cocktail bar Juniper.

We shared a pair of starters, but neither were quite right.

The stuck-together U-shaped bits of gluey treacle-cured salmon (ยฃ6.50) were OK in themselves, but theyโ€™d ditched the conventional partners โ€“ sweetness, zing โ€“ in favour of a bunch of unflattering accompaniments.

Every Scottish restaurant featured in the Michelin Guide 2026 - from cosy country pubs to townhouse tasting menus

There were quarters of not-peppery-enough radish, a nutty clumpy crumb of some sort, micro-herbs and, on a separate slate, a pair of plain linseed crackers.

All of which made for a dish that was dry in texture and flat in flavour.

Our set of sticky baby back Creole ribs (ยฃ6.50) were strangely ascetic too, with a gelatinous rather than sticky sauce, scrawny meat and almost zero seasoning, especially when it came to the apple slaw.

Things didnโ€™t improve much when it came to mains. The real stinker was the mackerel, mussel, prawn and shellfish broth (ยฃ13).

Who knows what made it a broth, perhaps it was a deconstructed version, or can be counted as such because of the meagre liquid elements โ€“ a daub of brown fishy stock and an algae-coloured โ€œwild garlic and spinachโ€ clotted jus smeared along the rim, like some dock leaf juice on a nettle sting.

20 of the best Edinburgh bars for watching rugby - where to see Scotland vs England and all the Six Nations matches

There was also a clump of dauphinoise potato topped by a piece of burnish-skinned mackerel, five in-the-shell cold mussels, and a handful of prawns, which were translucent in the middle.

We flagged up the uncooked element, and there was a prodding post-mortem over at the pass, then it was never to be mentioned again.

Our cod (ยฃ13) option was much better, once youโ€™d peeled back the floppy bandage of skin.

It came with a chilli-spiked beer sauce, a shoal of brown shrimp, tenderstem broccoli (described as burnt on the menu), and caramelised โ€œmalt onionsโ€.

A decent combo, at last, even if, initially, this option had come with a strange side โ€“ a second salmon starter โ€“ instead of the baby new potatoes (ยฃ3) side dish weโ€™d ordered.

Burns night supermarket deals: ยฃ1.99 haggis, ยฃ18 whisky and 47p neeps - from Asda to Aldi

My fillet steak (ยฃ28) was pretty pedestrian, with a clod of garlic and parsley butter on top, and a punnet of chips (which Iโ€™d accidentally ordered double of, since nobody pointed out that they came with the steak โ€“ ยฃ3).

Another addition of smoked bone marrow (ยฃ3) smelled amazing, but one halved bone had its emptiness disguised by a thatch of onions.

Their puddings are the best bit. We were cheered up by a fluffy and tropical-tasting lemon and mango cheesecake (ยฃ6), with pineapple chunks on top, a chevron stripe of mango coulis and a scoop of coconut ice-cream.

While, lime and blueberry posset, with crumbled (โ€œsmokedโ€) meringue, pistachio crumble and a powder they described as lemon sherbert (ยฃ5.50) was jammy and zingy.

Saved by the dessert, though I still think this restaurant needs to navigate some troubled waters.

They may continue to snag a few bridge twitchers by distracting them with an incredible view, but, to some people, including my sister, the Queensferry Crossing is just a road.

The Shore Grill & Fish House

Doubletree by Hilton Edinburgh โ€“ Queensferry Crossing, St Margaretโ€™s Head, North Queensferry, Fife
(01383 410 000, www.theshore-queensferry.co.uk)

 

Location:
Scotsman Review
Our criteria 
  • Ambience - It's important that a restaurant is inviting. We rate the decor, comfort and atmosphere.
  • Drink - Is the wine or cocktail list as exciting as the food, or does it fall short? Same goes for soft drinks.ย 
  • Food - We judge dishes on flavour, but also use of produce, cooking skill and presentation
  • Service - The staff and pace of a meal can make or break a meal out.
  • Value - From the food on the plate to service and surroundings, we check that you get what you're paying for.
Ambiance
7/10
Food
5.5/10
Total
0%
Gaby Soutar is a lifestyle editor at The Scotsman. She has been reviewing restaurants for The Scotsman Magazine since 2007 and edits the weekly food pages.
Copyright ©2026 Iconic Media Group
Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy Policy
crosschevron-down linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram