These are the best and worst supermarket Christmas puddings available now

No Christmas dinner is complete without a portion (or two) of Christmas pudding.

Published 9th Dec 2020
Updated 9 th Aug 2023

With that in mind, here are our reviews of some of the best and worst supermarket Christmas puddings on offer for Christmas 2020.

ASDA Extra Special 9 Month Matured Luxury Christmas Pudding - £7

supermarket Christmas puddings

If you want your Christmas Day festivities to end on a bang, end them with a helping of Asda's 9 month luxury pudding.

Whilst this isn't the strongest pudding on this list, this entry leaves a pleasant after taste for those looking to carry on the Christmas party.

It still retains a delightful soft texture which holds together with the right fruit to nut ratio. Suitable for Vegetarians. 4/5

Iceland 6 month matured Christmas Pudding - £1

For those who enjoy Christmas puddings without copious amounts of alcohol, look no further than the first of Iceland's puddings - which also happens to be the most affordable Christmas pudding on our list.

This is a pleasant after dinner treat which is neither heavy or rich.

Consisting mainly of currants and raisins, it may also be a favourite for those who aren't fans of nuts in their pudding. Suitable for vegetarians. 3/5

Iceland Luxury 12 Month Matured Christmas Pudding - £4

Iceland's premium serving of Christmas pudding is definitely aimed at pudding fans who enjoy a lot of fruit in every bite.

Island cafe with stunning views to team up with Michelin-recommended Edinburgh restaurant for one-off supper club

Laced through the thick mix are little breaks of candied nuts and fruit to break up the texture - but watch your teeth.

There's no lack of flavour if you go with this pudding but it's unlikely to leave you with a boozy buzz. Suitable for vegetarians. 3/5

M&S Collection Vintage Christmas Pudding 18 Month Matured - £15

Out of all the puddings on our list, this seemed the most authentic - regardless of the vintage style bowl and cloth cover that's included.

The pudding is lacklustre in the booze department compared to other offerings, but more than makes up for it with an abundance of cherries and dried fruit. So if you plan on having a few more tipples on Christmas Day, this is the pudding for you. 4/5

M&S Collection Chocolate & Orange Christmas Pudding - £12

New Scottish restaurants added to the Good Food Guide

If you're not a fan of a traditional pudding, and instead prefer a chocolatey indulgence, Marks and Spencer's chocolate Orange pudding is definitely worth saving a place on the Christmas table for.

Cooking this alternative Christmas pudding is a sensory sensation that leaves your kitchen smelling of the citrusy zest of Christmas.

The pudding itself is best eaten in small doses due to the richness of the chocolate and orange combination. 4/5

Lidl Deluxe Luxury 24 Month Matured Christmas Pudding - £9.99

supermarket christmas puddings

Picture: Lidl

If puddings were reindeer, Lidl's deluxe Christmas pudding is the one guiding Santa's sleigh.

This pudding is as premium as the box it comes in, and worthy of its Quality Food Awards badge.

El Perro Negro and Ka Pao team up for kitchen takeover in Glasgow 

It is is packed with premium cognac-infused fruit matched with the right consistency of nuts, leaving a moreish rich after-taste. 5/5

Morrisons The Best 9 month matured Christmas Pudding - £8

This pudding is ideal if you plan to have Christmas dinner leftovers later in the day - it is a light palette cleanser.

But unlike other puddings on this list, you might mistake the cherry and cognac for treacle which holds everything together - meaning it doesn't fall apart in the mouth. 2/5

Sainsbury's Taste the difference 18 month matured Christmas Pudding - £9

Fans of a nutty Christmas pudding will enjoy Sainsbury's offering this year.

This is also a pudding for fans who appreciate a boozy pudding with not only a lacing of cognac, but also rum and cider as well for a fruity flavour that's delicate but not overpowering. 4/5

Tesco Finest 12 month matured Christmas Pudding - £8

Overall, this 12 month matured pudding has a nice soft texture and light blend of fruits.

The cherries are soaked in brandy and are definitely sought after in every bite. Surprisingly citrusy which gives you a Christmassy feel and leaves you wanting more. 4/5

Waitrose No.1 Cherry & Almond Christmas Pudding - £14

Picture: Waitrose

If you want you Christmas dinner to end in a Christmas sing-song, this is the pudding that will help you to do that.

You can taste the infusion of rum, brandy and even a splash of amaretto in every bite of this pudding.

There is a nice consistency throughout with right amount of fruit and nuts carol, making this a firm favourite on this list. 5/5

Words: Craig Sinclair

These are the best and worst supermarket proseccos available for Christmas

Copyright ©2024 National World Publishing Ltd
Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy Policy
crosschevron-down linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram